Clegg vs. Cameron: disdain and scorn masked.

Thursday’s leaders’ debate was nowhere near as smooth as we might have expected. At the outset, each of the speakers appeared nervous. Non-verbally, I found the interaction between Nick Clegg and David Cameron most interesting. Given greater pressure, I wonder how civil they can remain? Tactically, I’d like to see the LibDems test it.

At 13’50”, Clegg’s visibly relaxed & moves to face Cameron’s question. He’ll repeat this throughout, it shows him as unafraid and respectful of the other two’s words for example at 1:07’50” and 1:15’57”. Contrast the effect it leaves you with to Cameron staying clear of Clegg at 1:18’00”.

Cameron laughs to introduce scorn when putting his question at 14’11”, he repeats this at 33’22” to no greater effect. Clegg’s echo of the initial laugh is forced, he’s leaking disdain. He turns back to the audience and camera to give his answer, cut the others out and build rapport and relationship. Cameron almost scowls at 14’19” when he realises that he’s lost the point and that Clegg won’t be easy to belittle. This is repeated at 54′.

At 1:15” Clegg surprises Cameron with his attack. Cameron’s eye movements suggest he’s processing and trying to imagine a response but instead he attacks Brown.

Clegg picks the wrong competition at 1:20′, bidding against Cameron in an auction to win the cheezefest. It’s a wonder that they don’t start referring to the “Great British Public” save that this would reduce the number of times they can say “care” whilst looking doey eyed into the camera. Both increase the speed and tone of their voices to a similar rate. Notably, at 1:22’04”, Brown contrasts this and sounds poised and authoritative. 1:25’05” is the most interesting point in the debate for me. Clegg can’t acknowledge Cameron by name and contrasts other points in the debate in that he starts a speech following Cameron turned away from him. It’s not only a tactic of not agreeing verbally with your opponent that all the speakers will have been briefed on from watching Kennedy v. Nixon. Clegg chokes slightly rather than acknowledge Cameron. Has he conceded the point that he’s been out schmaltzed or does he find the man loathsome?

Read me first.


This is a trial version of a blog that I’m interested in writing. It will be about non verbal communication and group dynamics and part of my motivation in writing it will be to be in contact with other people who’re interested in the subject, rhetoric, etc. There’s scant content at the moment but this will change in the coming weeks.

The blog’s not currently available unless you have the address and if you have the address it should be because I sent it to you so that you can let me know what you think? Please do so by sending an e-mail message to bob {at} beck(.)name . Thank you.


Being Authentic: Content, Person and Position.

When authentic, Gordon Brown is comfortable with his content and could scarcely be more credible. He turns being didactic into a virtue. Stacked on top of this, is his position as Prime Minister, which is the only Gordon Brown we’re afforded. Whilst his predecessor sculpted a public persona to the point of over familiarity; Brown’s personal life, to coin a phrase, “is just that”.

Imagine a scale that runs between credible and approachable. At one end we have Sean Connery playing James Bond, no curves in his posture, hand gestures only to add emphasis and with palms facing down, his breathing low in his body, he pauses between words and has a voice that goes down at the end of words or phrases. The other end is the theme park version of Mickey Mouse, head and body in continuous child like movement, shrugging shoulders, high breathing and a continuous squeeking voice.

On this crude scale Brown has a lot in common with his compatriot. In this clip at NYU he’s at his default. Were it not for the fluidity and range of this hand gesturing, he’d appear overly stern and serious. Continue reading

The Sovereign and the Showboy.

Berlusconi behaving badly is a cliché and a proven media tactic that bolsters his domestic poll rating. Skip ahead to 0:30. Queen Elizabeth is sprightly in decapitating balórdo’s irreverance. There are a couple of points of interest, one is her use of the group’s dynamic and the other her uncharacteristic use of non verbals. In the first case, she uses the group – Berlusca’s peers – to sanction him. Speaking to this third point rather than having a two point dialogue allows her to separate the issue from their relationship and doesn’t afford him a reply. At a stretch, it’s very Fisher and Ury. For sure, switching from two point to three point communication is a good tactic when delivering bad news.

Secondly it’s worth noting that she adopts non verbals that contrast her, flagship-brand predictable, default. Typically, the Queen embodies credibility. A straight posture, arms at right angles, stoic expression and a voice that curls down at the end of her phrase. Here she has her palm up, arm curved and her voice goes up at the end of each word. She’s even moving with some fluidity. It’s all very approachable. Subtle but different. When someone departs from a predictable default, that part of their communication or speech gains more attention and will stick in our long term memory. At the end of the day, by 0:39, her guest is blended back into the group.

Pellentesque vitae elit

Sed aliquam est sit amet orci. Nam a urna. Sed vitae massa ut dui bibendum congue. Aenean sem magna, auctor vitae, euismod in, iaculis sit amet, arcu. Duis augue. Maecenas dictum iaculis mi. Pellentesque elit nisl, lacinia et, aliquet sit amet, gravida sit amet, arcu. Vestibulum consectetur ante nec diam. Vivamus urna enim, auctor vitae, imperdiet in, aliquam sit amet, enim. Pellentesque nulla neque, venenatis non, porttitor vel, laoreet ac, velit. Pellentesque vitae elit. Nam lacus. Nunc vel orci eu elit blandit molestie. Etiam sagittis tellus vitae enim semper aliquam. Nullam ipsum dui, aliquam nec, tristique et, luctus in, augue. Maecenas diam libero, aliquet vel, tristique quis, hendrerit et, dolor.

Integer libero tellus, lobortis eu, sollicitudin id, porta sit amet, est. Aliquam erat volutpat. Quisque laoreet venenatis purus. Curabitur velit mauris, auctor et, pellentesque id, facilisis dapibus, odio. Fusce pulvinar convallis est. Sed luctus sodales risus. Mauris placerat dolor sit amet tellus. Aliquam dignissim nunc eu odio. Fusce sapien. Duis a odio at lorem vestibulum tempus. Cras aliquam elit.

In et velit non nulla rutrum consectetur. Proin scelerisque feugiat nulla. Cras porta blandit neque. Quisque varius tempus sem. Aenean quis lorem. Nulla tempus nibh consectetur felis. Quisque vitae diam. Morbi in metus. Aenean tristique felis non enim. Morbi tempus, lacus ut aliquet bibendum, diam quam hendrerit metus, vitae hendrerit orci lorem non orci. Etiam venenatis nunc eget ante. Curabitur ultricies, arcu in tincidunt eleifend, est tellus molestie diam, a congue sapien eros vitae nunc. Pellentesque varius, massa quis porta blandit, sem purus blandit velit, et pellentesque urna augue at ligula. Suspendisse commodo. Sed nibh felis, varius at, placerat et, vehicula et, dolor. Etiam blandit augue ut libero. Maecenas sit amet nunc sit amet lacus blandit sollicitudin. Morbi eu eros suscipit nisl porttitor placerat.